Amount of times matter not. Were you sincere when you stated due to not having HDMI the 360 wasn't HD?
I am still waiting for a quote, all I could find were well reasoned comments from 2007 that the PS3 comes with Blu-Ray (high bitrate 1080p / 7.1 audio movies) and a harddrive (for example for storing HD trailers and such) by default and the 360 does not. PS2 games like God of War 2 maxing out DVD, thus PS3 with high definition assets would do well having more capacity.
Or the PS3 setup is more powerful and with the 360 due to tiling, having good HDR and (advertised as free) AA developers are pretty stuck to sub-HD resolutions for top games (IMO Bungie isn't simply incompetent or on a low budget).
And it's not like I did not write positives about the 360 neither. For example from 2007 "Regarding the interface the Xbox 360 sports a very colorful easy to use user interface". That was of course before the XNE update.